Harvest strategies (HSs) are considered best practice for fisheries management and are increasingly being used to achieve stakeholder objectives, including biological sustainability. However, the objectives of recreational fishers are poorly understood and rarely integrated into HSs, reducing the likelihood of achieving fisheries performance for the sector. This can marginalise recreational fishers and generate inequity in multi-sector fisheries. A first step to redressing this issue is to identify priority objectives of recreational fishers that can be incorporated into HSs. We developed a multi-phase approach to identifying and prioritising recreational fishing objectives and applied it to three fish stocks of recreational importance. Phases include: (1) an initial literature review of recreational fishing objectives; (2) workshops with recreational fishers to refine the objectives for specific stocks; 3) classification of objectives according to whether they can be achieved within a HS; 4) development of an objectives hierarchy, from broad-level objectives through to specific objectives that can be measured, and 5) elicitation of preferences from recreational fishers to identify priority objectives for specific stocks. We outline the application of our approach to the case-study stocks and implications for HS development.